Choosing the Right HCM Strategy: Migration vs. Transformation
Avoiding the “Lift and Shift” Trap: How to Unlock the Full Potential of Your New HCM System
Is Your Organization Considering a New HCM System?
Before going to market with an RFP for a new HCM system, clearly defining your objectives can help maximize the value of your implementation. One key objective to consider is your implementation approach: do you seek a full transformation, or are you simply looking to migrate your existing payroll to a new system? Understanding the difference between the two approaches and defining expected outcomes ensures that your new system delivers improvements and avoids potential pitfalls associated with a poorly planned implementation.
Lift and Shift or True Transformation? Setting the Right Implementation Goals
While most payroll vendors can remap existing configuration into the new system, true improvement requires more than basic migration. Avoiding the “Lift and Shift” approach and engaging in an implementation with clear objectives ensures meaningful enhancement.
Before beginning your implementation, clearly identify current pain points, new features you’d like to leverage, and measurable improvements you want to achieve. Without clear objectives, many organizations move into a new system without making meaningful improvements.
Both approaches will work, but they will lead to very different results. Most vendors can replicate your current setup with minimal adjustments. However, if you want to unlock the full potential of your new HCM system, a basic migration will not deliver the value you want.
The real opportunity lies in using the implementation process as a platform for improvement. By setting clear goals, addressing pain points and leveraging new features, you can redesign your updated system in a way that truly gets the most out of your investment. A thoughtful, objective-driven approach is what turns an HCM implementation into a truly meaningful system that the entire organization needs.
How to Choose the Right Implementation Approach
When moving to a new HCM system, you have a choice between a simple conversion and a transformative implementation. Each approach comes with its own set of advantages and limitations. Understanding the trade-offs will help you select the path that best aligns with your organization’s goals.
When a Simple Conversion Makes Sense
A simple conversion, often called a “lift and shift,” involves replicating your current system setup in the new platform with minimal changes. This approach may be appropriate in situations where speed and timing are essential, for example, an ownership change that requires a payroll transition on a tight deadline, limited resources, or merging new businesses. In these cases, a lift and shift approach is often the fastest way to complete the move.
Benefits of a Simple Conversion
- Uses standard templates provided by your vendor for straightforward mapping.
- Easier reconciliation of year-to-date balances during transition.
- Interfaces/reports need reconfiguration in both approaches, but with a simple conversion, adjustments tend to focus on adapting to new codes.
- Requires a shorter planning phase, allowing implementation to begin sooner.
- Leverage the expertise of your existing payroll team, who are familiar with current processes.
- Requires only minimal training, focused primarily on navigating the new system rather than rethinking how the work gets done.
Drawbacks of a Simple Conversion
- Misses the opportunity to resolve known challenges or inefficiencies in current processes.
- Often requires redefining old processes anyway, which can lead to unexpected delays in timelines.
- Limits the ability to take advantage of advanced features and capabilities offered by the new system.
- This can result in longer implementation timelines as outdated workarounds need to be re-created in the new system.
- Frequently requires customizations or workarounds to preserve legacy processes, adding unnecessary complexity.
Why Choose a Transformative Implementation?
A transformative approach goes beyond replication. It focuses on designing future-ready processes that take full advantage of your new HCM system’s capabilities. Rather than repeating the past, it positions your organization for growth, efficiency, and modernization. Since your existing system’s implementation, it is certain that your organization has changed. Recognizing these changes and needs will spell out new requirements for your implementation. For example, consider health benefits. Many organizations now have robust benefit administration, reporting and even interfaces through their benefit provider and can therefore simplify payroll by providing flat amounts directly from their statements. This would reduce the need to reconcile monthly, explain discrepancies as well as monitor formulas in your payroll system that are already provided. Employees are becoming comfortable with logging into the provider’s site for information on their benefits, and so they don’t need the information in the payroll system. Identifying redundancies and making changes to your new system will result in time savings and improvements.
Benefits of Transformative Implementation
- Full use of system functionality, delivering a better return on investment.
- Automation of manual tasks, improving accuracy and reducing administrative burden.
- Process redesign that directly addresses existing pain points and inefficiencies.
- Implementation strategies built around the strengths of the new system, rather than carrying forward outdated workarounds.
- Long-term alignment between your HR and payroll processes and your overall business goals.
While a transformative approach requires more upfront planning and engagement, it provides a stronger foundation for efficiency, scalability, and future growth.
Defining Clear Objectives
No matter the reason for adopting a new HCM system, setting clear, measurable objectives is one of the most important steps in ensuring successful implementation. Well-defined goals allow your implementation team to design solutions that not only meet immediate needs but also support your long-term business strategy.
Many vendors provide templates for current payroll codes, and it is common to simply list them and then duplicate them. An example of how to make these improvements would be to review the completed templates and consider improvements, add new streamlined codes, and dedit for consistent font and case (all upper or all lower). Identify ways to reduce, streamline, or even expand where it makes sense. Only sign off on the template once your desired improvements have been captured. It is also recommended to share the vision with the implementation consultant and request insight and recommendations.
You might want to consider these other implementation/system objective examples and before you go live, check that they are being delivered:
- Automate general ledger (GL) integration with your financial systems to reduce manual effort and improve accuracy.
- Simplify payroll reconciliation.
- Improve payroll code descriptions resulting in providing employees with clearer, more transparent pay statements.
- Gain greater control over tax remittances to reduce compliance risks.
- Reduce calls to your service provider for changes/corrections to calculations.
- Automate pay increases and other recurring updates to improve efficiency and reduce errors.
By establishing clear objectives like these, your organization can make the most of its investment in a new HCM system. The more intentional you are about defining success, the better positioned you’ll be to drive real improvement and long-term value.
The Bottom Line: Define Your Goals to Choose the Right Path
Ultimately, choosing between a simple migration and a full transformation comes down to your goals. If speed and continuity are the priority, a simple conversion might be the right fit. But if you want to unlock the full potential of your new HCM system and position your organization for future growth, a transformative implementation is the stronger choice. Defining your objectives is what ensures you select the right approach for your organization and avoid falling into the lift and shift trap.
Barbara Positano
System Consultant, HRIS (UKG)
